9 December 2022

With entertaining parables the two conversationalists glide through the paradox of using words for the indescribable. They find that achievement in business or scientific ambition are not mutually exclusive with the quest for spiritual answers. To the contrary. 

0:00 Rajive lives now in the USA after a successful international career in business. He continues his life-long marveling at the significance of humanity and offers significant insights. 

02:34 How to get onto a board of directors – excerpt of Sarder TV’s interview. Intrinsic motivation: “I do what I love to do.”

05:40 Rajive has been in awe of the meaning of life from his childhood in India on. It brought forth an international career in banking as much as encounters with saints and gurus.

08:33 Is India particularly inducive to spiritual consciousness? An open and tolerant upbringing gave Rajive access to Christianity, Hinduism and Islam.

10:54 Eloquent, yet at a loss of words? Discovering a profound point in a contest at a Convent Girls College: The powerful value of a full stop versus the inadequacy of words.

13:54 The simple question ‘where are you from?’ triggers a deeper reflection of existence and the impossibility of words describing fully one’s experience of being one with all there is.

17:49 How then to describe what is indescribable? The Hindu methodology ‘Neti Neti’ (not this – not that) offers an answer. It is exemplified with the parable of the emperor discovering reality.

21:24 Deepak Chopra’s definition of Guru. There can be abuse and commercialization in gurudom. But also solace and peace. 

24:07 A distinction: There is no teacher without students. A Guru just is. Teaching can be with and without words, at the individual level of the recipient.

26:17 Selective perception. Empiric science validates spiritual experiences and engineering background helps teaching Reiki.

29:34 Science explains and searches what already exists. In Vedic scriptures our questions have already been asked and answered. Science and spirituality are compatible.

31:53 An attempt to explain consciousness with another analogy of an Indian prince learning of the wisdom of silence from a peacock’s squawks.

34:54 Today’s jesters at court are our TV comedians who are bringers of news and truth.

36:30 Gratitude to parents, to body-mind and for consciousness to discern between what is real and what is not, what is reaction and what is response.

38:34 A final anecdote involving Balsekar Ramesh concluding: “The purpose of life is to live.” Full stop.

Rajive Johri

a seasoned, broad based, professional Business Leader/ Director/Community leader with global experience, retired in September 2022. His background includes global leadership roles and board positions. He is an energetic and creative team leader with excellent communication and organizational skills with an outstanding track record of Brand Building, Strategic Marketing & bottom-line achievements.

Rajive has been serving on the boards of ConAgra, Charter Communications, Citicorp Trust Bank fsb, Boys Town USA and Lighthouse International. He was President of First National Bank of Omaha, Executive Vice President with J.P. Morgan Chase Bank and prior to that, he spent 16 year with Citicorp.

Rajive has had an ongoing interest in alternative Healing and Spirituality. He became a Reiki Master in 1993 and has served clients from the business- and banking community since then. He is a lifelong student of the Advaita philosophy.

Today Rajive lives with his wife Indrani in New York City and West Palm Beach, Florida. He enjoys golf and bridge.

LinkedIn profile: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rajivejohri

References

02:34 Full interview by Sarder TV: https://sardertv.com/author/rajive-johri/
15:30 Taoism and Tao Te Ching: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taoism#…
16:36 Ramana Maharshi: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramana_…
17:54 Neti Neti: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neti_neti
22:37 Deepak Chopra: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deepak_…
24:27 and 38:34 Ramesh Balsekar: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramesh_…
27:26 The Nobel Price in physics (quantum physics): https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/phy…
31:47 David Chalmers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_C… and ‘The hard Problem of conciseness’: https://iep.utm.edu/hard-problem-of-c…
39:56: Book: Consciousness Speaks – Conversations with Ramesh S. Balsekar, 1992

Feedback

Sponsors

Interested in sponsoring this or future RTalks?
Just get in touch with us!

More information about sponsoring can be found here.

0:00:00.000,0:00:07.518
Welcome to RTalk, the place where we agree to disagree.

0:00:07.520,0:00:10.398
My guest today is Rajive Johri.

0:00:10.400,0:00:17.410
Our topic is 'Loss of words'.

0:00:25.280,0:00:26.918
Hello Rajive, how are you?

0:00:26.920,0:00:28.990
How are you, ...
0:00:00.000,0:00:07.518
Welcome to RTalk, the place where we agree to disagree.

0:00:07.520,0:00:10.398
My guest today is Rajive Johri.

0:00:10.400,0:00:17.410
Our topic is 'Loss of words'.

0:00:25.280,0:00:26.918
Hello Rajive, how are you?

0:00:26.920,0:00:28.990
How are you, René? Good to see you.

0:00:29.920,0:00:30.710
Same here.

0:00:30.840,0:00:34.998
You're currently, I guess, in Florida. Is that correct?

0:00:35.090,0:00:36.598
I am in sunny Florida.

0:00:36.600,0:00:38.900
It's a beautiful view out of the window.

0:00:38.900,0:00:42.650
So, pretty distracting, but I think you are more appealing.

0:00:42.740,0:00:44.950
...

0:00:45.640,0:00:49.510
Here is sun setting. It's still a nice view, but more importantly,

0:00:49.610,0:00:53.158
the lake in front of my house, I visited it this afternoon.

0:00:53.160,0:00:56.798
It was 14 degrees Celsius, really cold.

0:00:56.800,0:01:00.398
Oh, yeah, it's 26 degrees here.

0:01:00.400,0:01:02.940
Well, there we go.

0:01:03.880,0:01:08.050
Rajive, I'd like to spend a few words to my viewers,

0:01:08.100,0:01:12.450
introducing you a little bit, as best as I can.

0:01:12.450,0:01:15.640
Some of it was already said.

0:01:17.930,0:01:21.090
You are living in Connecticut and also in Florida,

0:01:21.090,0:01:24.500
I guess you're alternating depending on the climate.

0:01:24.690,0:01:28.340
I moved to New York City from Connecticut.

0:01:28.600,0:01:32.878
Okay. Oh, you're no longer in Connecticut. You're in New York City?

0:01:32.880,0:01:34.860
This summer we moved. Yes.

0:01:34.890,0:01:37.940
All right. Good. Still, same thing applies:

0:01:37.940,0:01:40.980
probably depending on the season, you're up there.

0:01:41.260,0:01:41.930
Yes.

0:01:42.030,0:01:45.770
I met - dear viewers - Rajive 30 years ago in Hong Kong,

0:01:45.800,0:01:52.438
when we both trained to become Reiki teachers, Reiki masters.

0:01:52.440,0:01:56.650
At the time, Rajiv was an executive at Citycorp.

0:01:57.080,0:01:59.580
And he was busy with a banking career,

0:01:59.580,0:02:05.790
ending with him sitting on a number of boards of directors

0:02:05.850,0:02:11.860
from which last month, I think he resigned from the last seat.

0:02:13.040,0:02:20.310
For the framing of our ... philosophical, spiritual conversation 'Loss of words',

0:02:20.750,0:02:28.420
I'd like to give you a little bit of a spread and show you the world where Rajiv has come from

0:02:28.960,0:02:34.060
and show you an excerpt from a video(-interview) he gave a few years ago.

0:02:34.240,0:02:39.518
...the process that you followed to actually get onto a board?

0:02:39.810,0:02:43.140
Well, in my case, the process was purely accidental.

0:02:43.720,0:02:46.278
It wasn't something that I was actively out doing.

0:02:46.280,0:02:48.920
I mean, I was doing what I love to do, which is...

0:02:50.160,0:02:54.930
You know, Rajive, this was the key sentence to me when I did my research.

0:02:55.680,0:02:57.940
We spoke, what last Wednesday,

0:02:58.210,0:03:02.900
and I did a little bit research on you, what could I find on the net?

0:03:02.900,0:03:04.918
And I came across this interview.

0:03:04.920,0:03:08.670
And this sentence: "I do what I love to do" ...

0:03:08.770,0:03:15.820
Because, you may know I'm quite busy with reinventing organisations of all kinds,

0:03:15.820,0:03:21.760
and I think the key element today and for the future of organisations,

0:03:21.760,0:03:29.238
but also of schooling, is actually intrinsic motivation, allowing to do what one does.

0:03:29.240,0:03:31.038
I think that's something very important.

0:03:31.040,0:03:37.430
Who knows, maybe later we get back to it, but let me continue with the video.

0:03:39.120,0:03:41.878
Give my time to external forums.

0:03:41.880,0:03:47.998
So associations, community activities, not-for-profit.

0:03:48.000,0:03:50.920
I was raising funds for United Way.

0:03:51.240,0:03:53.750
I joined the board of some not-for-profits.

0:03:54.240,0:03:57.930
I was visible in the community. I was part of the Chamber of Commerce

0:03:58.430,0:04:01.210
and giving speeches in associations.

0:04:03.560,0:04:07.718
(Accidental interruption.)

0:04:07.720,0:04:11.500
... visible. So not only I was visible in my own industry of banking,

0:04:12.110,0:04:14.240
but I was visible in other forums as well.

0:04:14.680,0:04:17.810
So as a result, I got a recruitment from,

0:04:18.200,0:04:21.358
they approached me to join the board of a cable company.

0:04:21.360,0:04:23.750
So that's how I joined Charter Communications.

0:04:24.040,0:04:27.250
Because I was visible in the community, then people would ask me to join

0:04:27.250,0:04:29.310
the board of something or the other.

0:04:29.310,0:04:33.380
So I joined the board of Father Flanagan's Boys Town,

0:04:33.640,0:04:37.830
which is again a hundred year old organization, is a Catholic organization.

0:04:38.440,0:04:46.278
I had the unique privilege of being the first non-Christian chairman of a Catholic organization. Ever.

0:04:46.280,0:04:48.998
So I was chairman of Father Flanagan's Boys Town.

0:04:49.000,0:04:57.670
But all this happened because people saw me, people met me and they wanted me to participate.

0:04:58.330,0:05:02.238
So a lot of this ... this is also a question.

0:05:02.240,0:05:06.080
Is this a recipe to actually the success in your life?

0:05:06.140,0:05:14.180
This what I perceive curiosity to be out there in different fields, meeting people.

0:05:15.450,0:05:21.130
I know we're not on the topic of loss of words, it's maybe still searching for words,

0:05:21.570,0:05:27.880
when you were making yourself available to the marketplace, to society in general.

0:05:28.240,0:05:34.830
Tell me a little bit about this inert, intrinsically motivated curiosity.

0:05:34.840,0:05:37.870
Am I right in what I am assuming here?

0:05:38.040,0:05:40.838
Yes, you are, René.

0:05:40.840,0:05:46.300
I go back a long, long time when I was maybe nine, ten years old

0:05:46.610,0:05:51.118
and playing out with my buddies on the field.

0:05:51.120,0:05:56.918
And at the end of it, when you sat down in the evening and we were just chit chatting

0:05:56.920,0:06:01.398
and people were talking about all kinds of mundane stuff and I would look at the sky

0:06:01.400,0:06:08.398
and see the moon and the stars and I would wonder the significance of each one of us

0:06:08.400,0:06:13.158
and what we were saying or what we were spending time on.

0:06:13.160,0:06:17.820
So that's something that I didn't decide to do.

0:06:18.240,0:06:22.550
It just a thought which came to me and I didn't realize at that time,

0:06:22.550,0:06:27.238
but later on it struck me that that's not how everyone else was thinking.

0:06:27.240,0:06:30.580
It was something that was coming from within.

0:06:32.800,0:06:39.630
That's something which has taken me through my life, brought opportunities,

0:06:39.870,0:06:43.958
presented saints, people and things.

0:06:43.960,0:06:48.400
But it's not something that I actively chose to do.

0:06:50.400,0:06:52.840
You know, it just happened.

0:06:55.320,0:07:01.838
This is why I wanted to make a little bit of an excursion into your banking world because

0:07:01.840,0:07:10.870
for most people that's quite a stretch because they also heard your interest in spirituality.

0:07:12.160,0:07:16.540
And obviously, you know, the title which we have chosen is

0:07:16.540,0:07:21.910
directly alluding to spiritual or philosophical questions.

0:07:23.520,0:07:30.318
So, how did you come out ... where did you grow up?

0:07:30.320,0:07:38.758
You grew up in India great deals and where was the jump off to the executive world?

0:07:38.760,0:07:40.918
Can you briefly lead us through this?

0:07:40.920,0:07:41.918
Sure.

0:07:41.920,0:07:44.910
You know, I grew up in Delhi.

0:07:46.250,0:07:52.710
Growing up there, I did my schooling there and then I did my undergrad

0:07:53.440,0:07:58.310
in the engineering college called IIT Delhi in Delhi.

0:07:58.800,0:08:06.550
In those days, we are now talking about mid-60s when I went to my undergrad school at the age of 16,

0:08:06.710,0:08:10.110
you know, engineering was considered to be the best career. It wasn't something ... once again,

0:08:10.110,0:08:13.438
at the age of 16, I didn't know what I wanted to be.

0:08:13.440,0:08:15.790
I just knew that I wanted to do something

0:08:16.020,0:08:23.030
and I kind of got guided into a competitive exam, got selected and there I was studying engineering.

0:08:25.160,0:08:32.010
Would you say that you're ... I did meet your mother of course many, many years ago.

0:08:33.600,0:08:40.820
Would you say that you grew up in a specifically spiritual, for the lack of a better word,

0:08:40.940,0:08:44.638
spiritual environment, a spiritually conscious environment?

0:08:44.640,0:08:48.278
Was that true for your family or your environment?

0:08:48.280,0:08:52.430
Or is it in fact true for India as a whole?

0:08:52.720,0:08:59.198
Because the Prime Minister in the UK, is of Indian descent.

0:08:59.200,0:09:04.270
Okay, I think he was born in the UK and he's through and through British, of course.

0:09:04.270,0:09:13.638
But still, I'm curious about ... in your specific case, whether the spiritual environment was

0:09:13.640,0:09:20.558
present and had already a influence on you or whether you even think that this was like

0:09:20.560,0:09:24.758
everyday's life and this is how India still ticks today.

0:09:25.400,0:09:29.670
Well, India has changed a lot since... When we were growing up, you know,

0:09:29.680,0:09:34.420
I was born when India got independent and became a republic in 1950.

0:09:35.120,0:09:41.320
I grew up in a home where education was of highest priority.

0:09:43.010,0:09:47.290
My parents, pretty open minded, even though, you know,

0:09:47.500,0:09:52.398
India is highly religious, but that doesn't mean it was segregated religious.

0:09:52.400,0:10:02.350
We celebrated every religious festival, whether it was Hindu, Muslim, Christian, so it was pretty open.

0:10:02.350,0:10:12.020
I read most of the religious literature about Hindu, Christian and Islamic before I was 10.

0:10:12.110,0:10:16.518
I was allowed ... There was no prohibition on reading Quran or anything.

0:10:16.520,0:10:19.550
It was just, I was allowed to do what I felt like doing.

0:10:19.550,0:10:33.640
So I wouldn't say it was a spiritually inclined, but it was an open, accepting, tolerant inclined middle class upbringing.

0:10:34.950,0:10:38.080
We were allowed to do what we wanted to do.

0:10:39.010,0:10:47.598
And here we are, so many years later, we have a topic: loss of words.

0:10:47.600,0:10:54.110
And I have to look, because I wasn't sure is it 'lost for words' or is it 'loss of words'?

0:10:54.680,0:11:04.010
And I'm listening to you, so rhetorically, so eloquently, you express yourself.

0:11:04.010,0:11:10.270
And yet, when we spoke last Wednesday about the possibility of having a discussion today,

0:11:11.490,0:11:16.638
you actually said, you're a little bit at a loss of words.

0:11:16.640,0:11:19.420
And I picked that up and I said, that's a good topic.

0:11:22.440,0:11:28.880
Say something to why is 'loss of words' for us today such an important topic?

0:11:29.720,0:11:32.278
I think you picked it up right.

0:11:32.280,0:11:36.140
To me, it's both 'loss of words' and 'lost for words'.

0:11:36.600,0:11:43.558
It reminds me of an incident in 1972 or 73.

0:11:43.560,0:11:52.170
I was doing my grad school in business and we were invited to another Convent College of girls

0:11:52.200,0:11:57.000
where one of the ladies who's now a friend of ours, she was running a contest.

0:11:57.440,0:12:03.558
And the contest was that you had to fill in blanks and the person chosen for the best comment

0:12:03.560,0:12:06.750
was going to get a prize from the mother superior.

0:12:07.320,0:12:12.680
And the filling the blanks was she had written on a board: Happiness is

0:12:13.400,0:12:14.398
And we had to fill in the blanks.

0:12:14.400,0:12:17.638
And a lot of people wrote many words and so on.

0:12:17.640,0:12:22.340
And I just went there and put a full stop after "is".

0:12:22.650,0:12:25.280
(laughter)

0:12:26.990,0:12:34.760
You know, people didn't laugh as much as they were very skeptical and thought I was being smart-alecky.

0:12:35.220,0:12:37.990
But what they didn't know that I actually meant it.

0:12:39.130,0:12:43.358
Until today, when I think of words,

0:12:43.360,0:12:49.890
all those words which are put after "Happiness is ...." couldn't explain what happiness is.

0:12:51.030,0:12:54.120
But I thought my full stop did.

0:12:56.870,0:13:06.910
Words, to me, while I've had to use a lot of words in all my life and my working life, personal life, you can't avoid it,

0:13:07.660,0:13:14.790
but I find the words sometimes cause more confusion, sometimes complications.

0:13:15.290,0:13:22.400
And yet, they are not able to explain what is truly intrinsically felt.

0:13:23.440,0:13:29.440
So you know, other people give the example of if you try to describe what is sweetness,

0:13:29.960,0:13:33.010
no words can explain it, you just have to experience it.

0:13:33.840,0:13:38.490
So there is experience on one side and words on the other.

0:13:39.440,0:13:45.560
So similarly, when we're talking about any deeper or a lighter subject,

0:13:46.320,0:13:50.540
I get lost for words and how do I explain this?

0:13:50.960,0:13:54.030
So just to give you another simple example, you know,

0:13:54.050,0:14:00.918
I've lived in five countries and I moved around. I've lived in 14 different cities.

0:14:00.920,0:14:05.300
I've managed businesses around the world and as I moved around,

0:14:05.860,0:14:08.510
you know, when you're sitting next to somebody and meeting them,

0:14:08.510,0:14:14.750
one of the questions which is first asked is, where are you from?

0:14:16.920,0:14:20.678
And most people are very easily able to answer, hey, I'm from Connecticut.

0:14:20.680,0:14:25.240
I'm from this place, because that's where they grew up and they spent bulk of their lives

0:14:25.280,0:14:29.740
and I would say, oh, now what is this person asking me?

0:14:30.200,0:14:35.020
Am I an American? I am an Indian? I'm an Asian? I'm what?

0:14:35.400,0:14:37.340
And where am I from?

0:14:37.640,0:14:42.850
So I would be at a loss for words in those situations.

0:14:43.240,0:14:48.740
So a normal explanation could explain where I was from because I was from everywhere

0:14:48.960,0:14:50.570
And I was from nowhere.

0:14:53.300,0:15:00.140
Well, of course, you know, the child who put the full stop after 'Happiness is' - a full stop -

0:15:00.140,0:15:05.800
and the grown up who is being asked, where are you from, and is pondering that,

0:15:05.800,0:15:14.590
in the background of all of that is of course a more deeper reflection of existence as a whole.

0:15:14.880,0:15:25.358
And ... When we met in Hong Kong and you did your own studying, I did my own studying,

0:15:25.360,0:15:30.878
we had moments together, particularly revolving around Reiki.

0:15:30.880,0:15:43.150
But one of the books I got attracted to was, let me just get it here, the I Ching

0:15:44.480,0:15:54.900
describing Tao and the very first sentence of the 'bible' for all the Taoists in the world, the I Ching says:

0:15:55.010,0:16:01.070
"The Tao that can be described, is not the eternal Tao.

0:16:01.520,0:16:05.990
The name that can be spoken is not the eternal name."

0:16:06.540,0:16:15.438
And quite similarly, of course, in Jewish religion, there is no name or the name of

0:16:15.440,0:16:20.400
God is not being uttered because it is beyond words.

0:16:20.720,0:16:31.918
And that child, when it made a full stop already had subconsciously or whatever way, obviously

0:16:31.920,0:16:35.920
at that time you hadn't read any of the smart books,

0:16:36.700,0:16:44.118
because Ramana Maharishi is of course the essence of ... What he's saying is exactly that.

0:16:44.120,0:16:47.118
"We are now in the very moment."

0:16:48.140,0:16:51.718
Obviously that was present at that moment.

0:16:51.720,0:16:59.900
And that knowledge, that wisdom, that enlightenment of the child just making a full stop there,

0:17:02.370,0:17:16.718
that is a moment of awe, of splendor, of consciousness being truly one with everything.

0:17:18.010,0:17:21.690
Like the essence of the Namaste greetings.

0:17:22.720,0:17:27.220
I've mumbled on, would you agree more or less or rather

0:17:27.220,0:17:30.530
would you expand on what I said if you do agree?

0:17:30.840,0:17:35.090
Yes. And that is where the topic comes into play,

0:17:35.090,0:17:43.718
which is that we are now into a subject where language is limited.

0:17:43.720,0:17:49.158
It is not capable of describing or expressing.

0:17:49.160,0:17:54.700
So, from the old days, the methodology which was used was ...

0:17:54.820,0:18:01.670
One of them you cited in the Taoism and in the Hinduism it's called 'Neti Neti', means not this, not this.

0:18:03.450,0:18:12.438
So they used a couple of techniques to explain or attempt to describe what is indescribable.

0:18:12.440,0:18:16.880
And one of them was not this, the other one is using pointers,

0:18:17.520,0:18:21.620
because something you can point to but you cannot describe it.

0:18:22.050,0:18:27.250
One of the stories which I came across later on is a mythological story in the Indian system

0:18:27.550,0:18:32.358
which is, there used to be an emperor and he was the most powerful emperor.

0:18:32.360,0:18:40.358
He had everything he wanted and all the wealths, everything was at his disposal.

0:18:40.360,0:18:47.398
And one night he had a nightmare and in the nightmare he sees that his kingdom was attacked

0:18:47.400,0:18:52.850
by another king and despite his being the most powerful, he is defeated

0:18:53.010,0:18:58.340
and he's arrested and he brought in chains in front of the other king

0:18:58.480,0:19:05.810
who mistreats him and finally takes away everything from him and exiles him into the forest.

0:19:06.200,0:19:12.000
So he goes into the forest and he has not eaten for several days

0:19:12.000,0:19:14.110
and he's looking for food and he's saying:

0:19:14.140,0:19:17.320
"What happened? I had everything and now I have nothing."

0:19:17.680,0:19:22.558
And he's searching for foods for days and he's literally crawling, scared of animals

0:19:22.560,0:19:28.400
and so on and suddenly he sees a half-eaten apple on the ground.

0:19:28.640,0:19:34.480
He runs for it and he grabs it. Just as he's about to take a bite,

0:19:35.010,0:19:40.830
a squirrel jumps and snatches the apple from him and he doesn't have that.

0:19:40.960,0:19:43.900
He lies down on the ground and he starts howling.

0:19:44.580,0:19:46.060
And then he wakes up.

0:19:46.640,0:19:51.180
He wakes up on his royal bed and he's got everything.

0:19:52.580,0:19:55.010
And he sits up and he says:

0:19:55.840,0:19:58.330
"Is this real or was that real?"

0:19:59.460,0:20:03.670
He keeps repeating this sentence and everyone comes and says, what happened to the king?

0:20:03.940,0:20:08.350
And the queen comes and the princess comes and everyone comes and he says:

0:20:08.780,0:20:10.980
"Was that real or is this real?"

0:20:11.340,0:20:13.038
So he wouldn't do anything else.

0:20:13.040,0:20:17.470
So finally one of the gurus in the kingdom came and met him

0:20:18.270,0:20:21.730
and he asked him, was that real or is this real?

0:20:22.520,0:20:28.540
And the guru says: "Were you there when you had nothing?"

0:20:28.930,0:20:31.630
He said: "Yes, I was there. I experienced it."

0:20:31.800,0:20:33.118
He said: "Are you here now?"

0:20:33.120,0:20:35.478
He was experiencing all this wealth.

0:20:35.480,0:20:36.478
He said: "Yes."

0:20:36.670,0:20:41.720
He said: "Well, neither that was real nor this is real. You are the only real."

0:20:42.670,0:20:43.370
Wow.

0:20:43.640,0:20:45.000
So ...

0:20:46.030,0:20:51.780
There is no other way of saying this except to provide a pointer.

0:20:53.900,0:20:56.078
This is a bit the dilemma we have.

0:20:56.080,0:21:02.590
I mean, it's a paradox that you and I should speak about this topic and use words to speak.

0:21:03.770,0:21:10.760
It's a little bit paradoxical and yet, of course in communication that's a very important part

0:21:11.030,0:21:17.740
even though it is well known that a great deal of our communication is actually

0:21:18.010,0:21:23.110
non-verbal even if we do use words and talk.

0:21:24.050,0:21:29.290
You know, listening to the story you just said and to the guru's advice ...

0:21:29.590,0:21:31.140
Before I get there ...

0:21:33.510,0:21:41.160
Say something about guru or gurudom, because I find that this is ...

0:21:41.180,0:21:48.250
and I'm talking to an Indian gentleman, so I want to grasp the opportunity and get rid of that question, because ...

0:21:49.210,0:21:56.560
The word is so often used in different ways and we Westerners we have a big hang-up about the word 'guru'.

0:21:56.570,0:22:01.430
It's very 'esoteric New Age' and creates dependency and that kind of thing.

0:22:01.880,0:22:09.680
So, very often we tend to say, well, guru is just another way for 'teacher'.

0:22:10.740,0:22:14.080
From all I know that to some extent that is true

0:22:14.250,0:22:21.770
but it's making maybe small of something which deserves a little more elaboration.

0:22:21.850,0:22:23.120
Could you please?

0:22:24.000,0:22:31.070
It's an interesting question. I mean, I could expound on it and spend thousands of words.

0:22:32.040,0:22:37.318
This reminds me of the question ... The same question was asked to Deepak Chopra on

0:22:37.320,0:22:41.990
an interview by Larry King about 20 years ago.

0:22:43.250,0:22:47.900
I'm sure it is there on YouTube somewhere but I don't know whether you've seen it

0:22:48.250,0:22:53.970
but it reminds me every time somebody says or talks about guru that reminds me of that answer,

0:22:54.480,0:22:57.240
because the question was ... Larry says:

0:22:57.580,0:23:02.970
"Alright Deepak, can you tell me what is guru?"

0:23:03.780,0:23:07.920
And Deepak Chopra without batting an eyelid looked at him and he says:

0:23:08.050,0:23:10.020
"Spell guru to me."

0:23:10.980,0:23:13.670
And Larry says: "What?"

0:23:13.670,0:23:15.680
He says: "Yes, just spell guru to me!"

0:23:15.980,0:23:19.040
And Larry says: "G U R U ."

0:23:19.400,0:23:24.020
And Deepak replied, he says: "Gee, You Are You."

0:23:24.450,0:23:30.830
(Laughter.)

0:23:31.400,0:23:38.140
I don't think there is a better answer to that question than what Deepak gave.

0:23:38.380,0:23:40.850
I'm giving full credit to him. It's not my answer.

0:23:41.160,0:23:44.080
But, you know, of course you know there's gurudom,

0:23:44.490,0:23:49.640
which is often misused by many people,

0:23:49.680,0:23:56.170
it's commercialization playing on the sentiments and the fears and anxieties of normal human beings.

0:23:56.750,0:24:00.530
And people's ... But you know, some people find solace and peace in it.

0:24:00.660,0:24:06.850
And some people get jipped by it too. So let's forget the fraudster’s part of it.

0:24:07.190,0:24:10.850
The distinction that I would make between a teacher and a guru

0:24:11.020,0:24:13.300
is that there is no teacher without students.

0:24:14.220,0:24:19.150
And yet ... a guru just is.

0:24:19.650,0:24:22.890
Guru is there for the teaching.

0:24:23.640,0:24:26.180
For anyone who's ready to receive it.

0:24:27.050,0:24:35.530
So, you know, many of us - I know that you have too - been in front of gurus like Balsekar and other people.

0:24:36.210,0:24:41.200
And when you go there, there are number of people present

0:24:41.200,0:24:46.460
but each one takes away something different from the same words which are spoken or unspoken.

0:24:48.040,0:24:51.960
And that is because they are ready for that part of the teaching.

0:24:53.740,0:25:04.090
So I would say that a guru is imparting deeper knowledge to the level the recipient is ready for.

0:25:05.920,0:25:12.730
So the recipient would put probably his question in form of words

0:25:12.980,0:25:19.990
and the answer from a guru would be beyond words. Is that a fair summary of what you just said?

0:25:20.670,0:25:26.410
No, guru ... Some of the gurus give long answers and words as well

0:25:26.470,0:25:32.080
depending on the students that they accept - I shouldn't use the word student -

0:25:32.290,0:25:34.530
depending on the recipient who is present.

0:25:34.740,0:25:38.810
And they bring down the language to their level

0:25:38.990,0:25:45.490
and therefore the language being used for one individual can be misunderstood by another individual

0:25:45.560,0:25:48.770
who attributes different meanings to those words.

0:25:48.770,0:25:52.460
But those words were meant for that particular individual.

0:25:53.240,0:25:58.090
I've seen that happening. It has happened with me. It has happened with other people.

0:25:58.190,0:26:04.910
So, the guru has the ability to communicate at that level of the recipient.

0:26:06.280,0:26:08.450
Okay, I understand.

0:26:09.280,0:26:17.130
You know, you're touching again on an important thing that we hear things differently.

0:26:17.790,0:26:23.060
We have viewers out there listening to our conversation and basically each of them

0:26:23.310,0:26:27.480
is listening through his own filters through his own biography

0:26:27.920,0:26:34.140
and he will have consciously, subconsciously a degree of selective hearing with words.

0:26:35.510,0:26:43.220
And depending on his choice he of course will get his preconceived opinion validated,

0:26:43.960,0:26:52.480
or his choice may also be to reflect on his belief-systems and on his preconceived opinions

0:26:52.930,0:27:04.050
and be open to suggestion that maybe there is a degree of truth beyond that which he hears through his filters.

0:27:05.950,0:27:11.040
When you spoke earlier, when I interrupted you with the question of the guru,

0:27:11.890,0:27:17.010
it actually reminded me ... You've seen that

0:27:17.510,0:27:26.080
the Nobel Prize this year for physics was given to quantum physics which ...

0:27:26.410,0:27:31.970
Oh! How did I get into this spot trying to explain what quantum physics is ...

0:27:32.440,0:27:33.960
(Laughter.)

0:27:33.960,0:27:34.910
In words!

0:27:35.530,0:27:43.450
Basically, I think the award was given for the proof of something which in spiritual terms

0:27:43.590,0:27:51.590
has been known for a long time but in the world of empiric science

0:27:51.790,0:27:58.220
it has not been validated and that is in the quantum physical world that

0:28:00.090,0:28:09.330
one piece of light for example emanating from the same source going into different directions,

0:28:09.590,0:28:14.730
the moment you change one of those ends in the direction

0:28:14.800,0:28:19.470
no matter how far apart, how many zillions of light years they are apart,

0:28:20.270,0:28:26.560
the other, it's twin brother or twin sister, basically will respond to the change.

0:28:26.820,0:28:31.210
Actually, to the contrary, to the opposite and balancing.

0:28:31.570,0:28:39.200
And of course ... I'm at a loss of words right now. I don't know why my mind went there.

0:28:39.720,0:28:45.600
I see you nodding and giggling, can you maybe put sense to my own words, please?

0:28:45.840,0:28:49.090
Spirituality and quantum physics?

0:28:50.990,0:28:56.320
You know, in my times of teaching,

0:28:57.130,0:29:01.400
the students that I attracted were from the corporate world mostly.

0:29:02.400,0:29:09.380
And people would wonder that how is it that somebody like me who's in the corporate world,

0:29:10.090,0:29:12.540
international global corporate world,

0:29:12.890,0:29:16.980
was engaging in something which a lot of people would call it

0:29:17.410,0:29:20.970
'witchcraft', 'voodoo' and funny stuff and whatever.

0:29:22.190,0:29:26.430
One of the things that probably appealed to them because I attempted

0:29:26.430,0:29:31.330
- and I used to tell them that I'll make an attempt - to give a scientific explanation,

0:29:31.940,0:29:34.410
because of my scientific background.

0:29:34.480,0:29:40.090
But I always would also say that, look, science doesn't create anything.

0:29:40.720,0:29:46.710
Science by definition is only explaining what already exists

0:29:47.360,0:29:52.820
and is constantly endeavouring to keep on discovering what already exists.

0:29:53.020,0:29:53.640
Yeah.

0:29:53.980,0:30:00.910
Okay. So, you know, whether it's quantum physics or ... black holes

0:30:00.920,0:30:04.940
and creation of black holes and all that stuff, is just ...

0:30:04.990,0:30:11.140
Or talking about one million, billion, trillion light years away you suddenly take a picture of it

0:30:11.910,0:30:19.470
and put it on Facebook or whatever, it's you know, it's still so far removed from where we are.

0:30:20.000,0:30:24.000
Okay, and some people are ... You know, it's like ...

0:30:24.270,0:30:28.750
Just to bring it down to today's context of vaccines.

0:30:28.750,0:30:33.470
There are people who don't believe in vaccines. Okay, and some people believe in vaccines.

0:30:33.600,0:30:40.660
Now there is science which says this works but it also says it works only 85% of the time.

0:30:42.640,0:30:46.970
So, nothing that science says works 100% in any case.

0:30:47.940,0:30:52.000
As far as deep spirituality goes

0:30:53.100,0:31:00.820
the questions of spirituality have been arising ever since the existence itself.

0:31:01.300,0:31:05.550
And that is why the oldest of literature which exists,

0:31:06.000,0:31:11.960
at least, I mean, I'm aware of their existence in the Vedic system, in the Indian religions,

0:31:12.510,0:31:18.580
every question that we talk about today or try to answer has already been asked and answered.

0:31:18.600,0:31:24.810
I mean, it's amazing when I read some of the Upanishads and old literature

0:31:24.970,0:31:30.500
every question which is being asked has been asked multiple times

0:31:30.590,0:31:35.710
and has been answered. And debated. And re-debated in multiple times.

0:31:35.910,0:31:42.680
So, I don't see a contradiction between science and spirituality.

0:31:43.130,0:31:46.200
Science... That's why even scientists that today

0:31:46.200,0:31:52.230
- what's his name, David Chalmers who's written a book called 'The hard problem of consciousness' ...

0:31:53.240,0:31:59.020
he is trying to explain consciousness but you cannot explain it, you know but experience it.

0:31:59.260,0:32:03.100
But bringing it to the words is reminding me of another story,

0:32:03.280,0:32:09.110
which is of another king who had one prince, one son.

0:32:09.130,0:32:10.840
But this son never spoke.

0:32:11.250,0:32:17.310
So he was all the time worried that "my son doesn't speak; how is he going to take over and become the king?"

0:32:17.650,0:32:24.770
At any time anyway, the prince had grown up. He was about 20 years old and he still wouldn't speak.

0:32:25.220,0:32:29.810
So, you know, he called a lot of teachers and gurus and to help him

0:32:30.070,0:32:37.700
but this guy wouldn't speak so one day, one of his ministers went for a walk with this prince to the palace gardens.

0:32:38.320,0:32:44.580
And there, you know, they were, the minister was trying to make him speak by talking about different subjects.

0:32:44.960,0:32:51.820
You know, deep spiritual subjects and the politics, the war, whatever. But this guy wouldn't say a word.

0:32:52.760,0:32:59.980
While they were roaming around there was a peacock sitting on a tree.

0:33:00.700,0:33:08.120
And the peacock started speaking and making the sounds of 'pew pew' whatever.

0:33:08.380,0:33:12.740
And after some time this guy who was trying to make this guy speak got very irritated.

0:33:13.200,0:33:15.630
He took out his gun and shot the peacock.

0:33:16.380,0:33:22.310
And the peacock fell and this prince ran to the peacock

0:33:23.360,0:33:27.630
and picked him up in his lap and started caressing him and said:

0:33:28.300,0:33:32.900
"If only you had kept quiet and not spoken a word. You would be alive."

0:33:33.550,0:33:35.300
(Laughter.)

0:33:35.690,0:33:45.240
So, words, sound can create more trouble. And this prince innately knew that being the prince

0:33:45.690,0:33:48.558
he was the target in the palace politics.

0:33:48.560,0:33:50.360
So he wouldn't speak.

0:33:51.310,0:33:53.030
But it comes from within.

0:33:55.740,0:33:59.370
Other people didn't understand that he understood.

0:34:01.820,0:34:08.798
Nice. Nice story making a good point. You know it reminded me of Albert Einstein

0:34:08.800,0:34:13.180
who reputedly didn't speak for the first five years of his life

0:34:13.700,0:34:20.760
and then one Sunday morning they had breakfast and there was soft boiled eggs

0:34:20.870,0:34:26.100
and little Albert said: "Mommy the eggs are undercooked."

0:34:26.660,0:34:31.300
And the whole family said: "But Albert, you can speak! Why didn't you speak earlier?"

0:34:31.500,0:34:34.600
And he says: "So far the eggs have been alright."

0:34:35.180,0:34:38.350
(Chuckling.)

0:34:40.610,0:34:45.360
It's ... an interesting topic.

0:34:46.800,0:34:54.158
I find it very ... And we had a lot of ... Particularly you contributed with amusing stories which

0:34:54.160,0:35:01.078
were beautiful metaphors to transport of course a deeper meaning and I find it very amusing

0:35:01.080,0:35:10.478
that the modern news bringer today are like in the old days the fool again. You know,

0:35:10.480,0:35:17.210
the emperor always had a fool and the fool was the only one who was allowed to speak the truth.

0:35:18.070,0:35:25.718
And all the ministers of course were kowtowing and our fools today are actually

0:35:25.720,0:35:33.798
our comedians and it's amazing particularly during corona time it was very intense and during

0:35:33.800,0:35:39.358
political upheaval very often we get a lot of interesting information from the comedians.

0:35:39.470,0:35:43.150
More so than from the anchorman of the news stations.

0:35:43.820,0:35:56.180
So we are battling a little bit for words, even though we know that ultimately it's the full stop which says it all.

0:35:56.440,0:36:01.040
So we're coming towards an end of our conversation, Rajive.

0:36:01.960,0:36:09.020
Tell me a little bit how usually a few words, how are you right now?

0:36:09.240,0:36:17.950
And how are you in context with life ... how content are you in your life?

0:36:18.820,0:36:25.960
Share maybe somewhat of an insight which spontaneously comes to your mind.

0:36:26.350,0:36:28.480
It can be another joke if you want to.

0:36:30.990,0:36:37.540
Well. You know, I get up in the morning and the first thing I do

0:36:37.690,0:36:45.310
I thank for the experiences which this body-mind

0:36:45.350,0:36:49.590
which was brought into this world by my mother and father. So I thank them.

0:36:50.260,0:36:56.630
I thank the planet earth for hosting this body-mind.

0:36:57.310,0:37:01.640
And I thank this body-mind for being healthy

0:37:02.020,0:37:05.910
and giving me the experiences over the last 72 years.

0:37:05.910,0:37:14.670
It has given me wonderful experiences and this body-mind, and consciousness,

0:37:14.700,0:37:21.100
have given me experiences and the ability to discriminate between what is real and what is not.

0:37:21.940,0:37:29.680
It's so easy to get engaged and involved with the reactions of this body-mind

0:37:30.560,0:37:33.550
which are natural which is intrinsic, because of ...

0:37:33.710,0:37:37.990
you know, you can get into another talk on that as to why that happens and how that happens

0:37:37.990,0:37:44.390
but it does happen in that one responds - I remember this workshop

0:37:44.410,0:37:50.570
that you and I did together with John Veltheim which is response versus reaction.

0:37:51.400,0:37:59.630
So, you know, the body-mind reacts and sometimes our response gets engaged with the reaction.

0:38:00.920,0:38:13.810
It is the blessing - whether it's the blessing because of my gurus or angels or whatever -

0:38:13.990,0:38:19.700
intrinsically, which allow me to distinguish between the response and the reaction.

0:38:19.880,0:38:26.150
While the reaction is happening it seems I'm engaging but I'm not.

0:38:29.250,0:38:38.000
My life today is about going with the flow. I remember this question was asked once to Balsekar.

0:38:38.360,0:38:45.260
There was a Jewish gentleman from Argentina who had a very disturbed childhood

0:38:45.530,0:38:50.240
and he was sitting there and I was watching this conversation taking place with Ramesh.

0:38:51.150,0:38:55.760
After he listened to Ramesh for ... They had this interaction for more than an hour.

0:38:56.020,0:38:56.850
And then he said:

0:38:56.860,0:39:02.600
"So, what is the purpose of this life then if everything is just happening

0:39:02.600,0:39:06.810
as consciousness is doing everything in consciousness,

0:39:06.990,0:39:09.460
what am I supposed to do?"

0:39:10.500,0:39:13.640
And Ramesh gave a very simple answer. He said:

0:39:14.000,0:39:18.610
"The purpose of life is to live."

0:39:19.600,0:39:21.070
Full stop.

0:39:23.840,0:39:25.870
He said, just live.

0:39:26.680,0:39:29.960
There is nothing more, nothing less.

0:39:30.670,0:39:33.880
And of course in Bhagavad Gita Krishna says this to Arjuna as well.

0:39:33.880,0:39:40.160
But you know, all this brings you to the same point that I made earlier that, you know,

0:39:40.160,0:39:41.650
with all the words and everything,

0:39:42.010,0:39:46.900
every question is always already being asked and already been answered by someone.

0:39:47.720,0:39:54.700
And if it's only as a recipient, have we captured the essence of that question and answer?

0:39:55.790,0:39:58.120
That's why the book ... Ramesh (Balsekar's) book

0:39:58.120,0:39:59.770
which is the most popular book,

0:40:00.160,0:40:03.600
it doesn't say "Ramesh speaks", it doesn't say "Ramana speaks", it says:

0:40:03.960,0:40:05.940
"Consciousness speaks".

0:40:06.760,0:40:09.660
So it happens.

0:40:10.010,0:40:17.370
So I'm going with the flow. I'm, you know, relishing the joys which are served in front of me.

0:40:19.010,0:40:20.820
And ...

0:40:22.470,0:40:24.940
That's it.

0:40:25.770,0:40:32.630
You spoke and I heard that little boy saying happiness is. Full stop.

0:40:35.880,0:40:40.080
Thank you. I hope, I mean, I'm at a loss for words after this.

0:40:40.500,0:40:41.870
Join the club.

0:40:42.300,0:40:49.430
I just enjoyed that very brief moment of silence because it's a nice ending to our conversation.

0:40:50.670,0:40:56.620
You know what you said and that full stop which you made at the end of our conversation

0:40:56.620,0:41:02.150
and which you described which you made as a child at school.

0:41:03.630,0:41:08.990
The only thing left is for me to say thank you to you, to express my gratitude to you

0:41:09.250,0:41:11.630
that you invested some time here.

0:41:12.480,0:41:19.350
Thank you very much Rajive. I wish you a nice day still and I'm saying for now goodbye to you.

0:41:19.480,0:41:21.790
Thank you very much.

0:41:22.240,0:41:24.620
Thank you, René. Enjoy it too.

0:41:25.100,0:41:28.430
Namaste.

0:41:29.000,0:41:33.130
Dear viewers, thank you very much for having watched.

0:41:33.280,0:41:34.650
Please subscribe.

0:41:34.840,0:41:39.690
Please donate.
And most importantly watch again in three weeks time.

These transcripts are provided by LAFER 

Subtitles contribution

Already existing subtitles for this video:

English Deutsch Español Português (Portugal) Русский

If there are no subtitles for your language yet, you can make an enormous contribution with your translation.

Just fill out the form and we will contact you immediately with further details. Thanks a lot!

Might also interest you

Keep yourself up to date about new projects and RTalks!